Introduction
Ahhh, the dissertation topic…bane of a research student’s existence, more mythical than a unicorn and harder to track down than the Lost City of Atlantis!
In my previous posts, I shared some of my theories and insights into choosing a dissertation topic:
- Your first choice of topic doesn’t have to be your last
- The research topic depends on asking the right question
- Various tips for finding a dissertation topic
For this series of posts, I wanted to share a personal test case for how I arrived at my thesis. I hope that my search experience will spark different ideas for you as you track down that elusive dissertation topic.
The interest factor
One of the first things that guided my choice of a thesis was the interest factor. In other words, just how passionate or curious was I about the subject matter?
Now I don’t have any hard data on how many dissertation topics meet this criteria. All I know is that after 18 months of research, I can honestly say that writing a thesis is killer! I can’t imagine how I would be getting by without a strong sense of interest or passion for the topic.
A passion for leaders
Prior to applying to a PhD program, I spent four years teaching Bible and theology at a small Bible Institute in Paraguay, South America. And I loved it!
Thus for me, the whole topic of leadership development was at the very center of my ministerial world. Beyond good hermeneutics and theology, what key leadership principles did I need to cultivate in my students? What were some biblical models of leadership that were needed here in Latin America?
Sadly, one of the prevailing models of a church leader was that of an autocrat. This meant that God communicated his vision for the church solely through the pastor. In addition, the pastor had complete spiritual authority over the members of his church. (If this is how most pastors run their church, then perhaps I need to update my theology! :))
From passion to topical seed
When I returned to the U.S. to pursue additional studies, I did some serious reflection on my time at the Bible Institute. Many of the models of leadership I had witnessed were not healthy and yet I had been in a position to influence the direction of many future leaders. I also knew that I would be returning to a similar academic environment in the future.
In addition, as I began to read books on leadership here in the U.S. I realized how many of them had borrowed their techniques from the business world…pastor CEO, right?
It was then and there that I decided that I would be doing my research in the area of biblical leadership. I wanted to find out for myself what the scriptures had to say about this important topic. I was now a motivated and excited student!
The next step in the process was winnowing down the biblical / theological discipline in which to pursue my studies. But that will have to wait for another post.
Check back in later where I will continue my personal test case in choosing a dissertation topic.
Your comments are always greatly appreciated. I would be interested in knowing how you chose your topic and whether you chose something about which you were passionate.
Happy researching!
my topic came from my pre-grad school professional experience. i worked as an inpatient dietitian at a hospital, and often counseled these patients after surgery. i began wondering if those who knew what to expect regarding diet and weight loss (that is, who could tell me their dietary progression and plan before i opened my mouth) did better than those who couldn’t. i was also convinced that long term dietary changes (that is eating less and not eating high sugar, high fat foods) would not be maintained simply by the negative ramifications the surgery created (after this surgery it is impossible to eat more than a few ounces per meal and there are a lot of negative side effects related to eating high fat and high sugar foods). in addition, i find the topic (dietary and weight loss changes after obesity surgery) the perfect mix of physiology and psychology and as i’ve gone through school have learned more about metabolism, obesity, weight loss, health care and economic policies, behavior change theory, and statistics, all of which have helped me keep interested and prevented boredom. i cannot imagine being uninterested in one’s dissertation topic. sure i get sick of it at times or hate my dissertation, but in the end, i really like my topic and think i’m uncovering some fascinating and novel findings (if i do say so myself).
Amanda:
Very cool! I am always amazed at the number of disciplines, tangential subjects one has to cover in order to do good research. The “economic policies” piqued my interest. How exactly does that fit in with your topic and what are you suggesting be done on that front?
the economic policies are more background, as i do not deal with them specifically in my research. a main argument for why we should care about obesity is economic, as all the diseases associated with it are huge burdens on the health care system. people argue about food policies and government subsidies to corn and evil, giant food industries, but i think that simplifies the issue. it’s the modern way of life in general, of which what and how much we eat is only part (a large one, albeit, but not the only one).
in my opinion, more needs to be done to create an overall environment conducive to healthy living and insurance companies need to cover more preventative medicine as opposed to reactionary solutions like obesity surgery, which has been found to be a cost-effective treatment for obesity and is therefore covered by major insurance companies…because everything we do in policy in America has to boil down to money, which is a whole different set of issues.
Pingback: PhD Advice: A test case in finding a dissertation topic – Part 2 | Phd and Dissertation Advice
Pingback: PhD Advice: A test case for finding a dissertation topic - 3 | Phd and Dissertation Advice
Pingback: Phd Advice: A test case in finding a dissertation topic – Part 4 | Phd and Dissertation Advice